Residents Rally Behind Carrillo at Contentious RMA Meeting
Nov 19, 2026 03:17PM ● By Gail Bullen
Former Rancho Murieta Association Director Danny Carrillo makes his case against a skateboarding violation at the Nov. 17 RMA board meeting, accompanied by his dog, Leo, and surrounded by residents who turned out to support him. Photo by Gail Bullen
RANCHO MURIETA, CA (MPG) - An estimated 70 residents attended the Rancho Murieta Association board meeting Nov. 17 to support former Director Danny Carrillo in his dispute over a skateboarding violation. The meeting erupted in boos and angry protests when Carrillo approached directors to thank them and several walked away.
Carrillo said four directors either refused to shake his hand or walked away as he approached. In a formal response on behalf of the board, Director Chris Childs disputed Carrillo’s account, explaining that three directors had left to use the restroom before Carrillo offered them his hand.
The confrontation followed a lengthy public comment period during which residents repeatedly applauded Carrillo and questioned the association’s enforcement of its rules.
The board subsequently confirmed that it considered Carrillo’s appeal in executive session and reached a decision but declined to disclose the outcome, citing member confidentiality.
Carrillo received a violation notice Aug. 28 for riding his motorized skateboard while holding the leash of his dog, Leo. He maintains that neither he nor his skateboard was tethered to Leo and that he had ridden with his dogs through the community for more than a decade without being cited.
The RMA Compliance Committee upheld the violation Oct. 7, although no fine was imposed. Carrillo was scheduled to appeal the decision to the board in executive session Nov. 17 but declined to attend because, he said, his repeated requests for a public hearing had gone unanswered.
Instead, he presented his case during the members’ open forum.
Carrillo Makes His Case
Carrillo began with a demonstration, using a pole with a tetherball attached to illustrate his interpretation of the word “tethered.” He then brought out his skateboard and Leo, riding the motorized board while holding the dog’s leash.
“I’m not stationary. I’m moving and grooving,” he told the audience, drawing applause.
Carrillo, who served nearly five years on the RMA board before resigning in August 2025, followed with a prepared statement challenging the citation and criticizing what he described as declining transparency.
He cited the loss of the association newsletter, easy access to board meeting packets, general manager summaries and the communication committee. He also criticized the elimination of opportunities to comment on individual agenda items, the reduction of public comments to three minutes and restrictions on reporter access.
Carrillo said he believes the dispute goes beyond the citation and stems from questions he raised about association management and board decisions during his tenure as a director.
“Members have the right to know the answers to questions raised,” he said.
He urged the board to reverse the Compliance Committee’s decision and restore transparency by responding to emails, reinstating the “Contact the Board” feature on the association website and treating members equally.
“Rancho Murieta is a great community, and our association should welcome its members, not close the door on them,” he concluded to applause.
Director Scott Adams then attempted to explain Rule 9, Section 8(C), which prohibits a person riding or propelling a skateboard, bicycle or scooter from attaching the device or themselves to a vehicle, animal or bicycle.
Carrillo interrupted, asking Adams to send his explanation by email so other residents would have an opportunity to speak. Board President Patrick O’Hern questioned Carrillo’s unwillingness to hear the explanation after calling for transparency. Carrillo replied that he would prefer to consider it when he was less stressed.
Adams continued, arguing that the rule’s use of the word “attach” was broader than Carrillo’s interpretation of “tethered.” Carrillo interrupted again, saying he disagreed and did not want to debate the issue. Audience members also challenged Adams’ explanation, prompting O’Hern to strike his gavel and ask that Adams be allowed to finish.
Residents Question Citation
Eight other residents spoke in support of Carrillo, questioning the citation and the association’s enforcement of its rules.
Roger Formanek, a retired state attorney, argued that enforcing rules requires judgment and called the citation unreasonable. Paula Ramirez questioned why Carrillo had been cited when other residents routinely exercise their dogs while driving golf carts.
Greg Mahoney, Sacramento County’s chief building official, criticized Adams’ interpretation of the rule as “linguistic gymnastics.”
Other speakers described Carrillo and Leo as familiar, welcome sights in the community and urged the board to reconsider the citation. Several thanked the directors for their service while questioning whether pursuing the violation was worth the division it had created.
O’Hern said disciplinary matters are confidential and handled in executive session. He declined to discuss whether other residents had received similar citations.
Handshakes Spark Outrage
The most contentious moment came at the end of public comments.
Carrillo asked O’Hern for a short recess so residents who had come to support him could leave before the board continued its business. O’Hern declined, saying residents were welcome to leave while the board conducted business.
Carrillo then approached the directors to thank them, offering handshakes.
According to Carrillo, Director Ernie Cowles shook his hand, but Director John Van Doren looked at his extended hand, turned away and declined to shake it.
“John, I extended my hand, and he just looked at me and turned his head,” Carrillo said in a Nov. 19 interview. “I left my hand extended, and then everybody started booing.”
Carrillo said he continued along the dais, but Directors Chris Childs and Tom Reimers and President O’Hern walked away as he approached. Directors Scott Adams and Wyly Haviland, like Cowles, shook his hand.
The board members’ account differs.
In a written response to questions from the River Valley Times on Nov. 19, Childs said Carrillo never extended his hand to him, O’Hern or Reimers. “The details of that interaction are very important,” Childs wrote on behalf of the board.
He said residents were beginning to leave following the lengthy public comment period when three directors took advantage of the pause to use the restroom.
“When we came back, Danny had left the front of the room and was back by the rear doors of the meeting space,” Childs wrote.
Regarding the director who did not respond to Carrillo’s handshake, Childs said it would not be appropriate for the board to speak on behalf of an individual director.
Carrillo rejected the explanation. “They knew what I was going to do, because I was going right down the line,” he said.
He said the directors had just refused his request for a recess, making their departure particularly surprising. “From my perspective, it’s hogwash,” he said.
Board Defends Appeal Process
Childs also responded to Carrillo’s criticism of the handling of his appeal.
Carrillo acknowledged receiving a letter notifying him of the hearing date and time. However, he maintained that despite repeated requests, he never received a response addressing his request to have the appeal heard in open session.
Childs disputed that account, saying Carrillo received more than one written response from General Manager Vicky Lentz concerning his request.
The decision to conduct the hearing in executive session was made on advice of legal counsel and in accordance with the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, Childs said.
He said Carrillo was in the building when an RMA staff member invited him into executive session.
“Danny refused to attend his hearing and speak to the board,” Childs wrote.
Nevertheless, the board considered the appeal and reached a decision, Childs said. He declined to disclose the outcome, citing Carrillo’s right to privacy.
Childs also addressed residents’ concerns about selective enforcement.
“RMA staff continues to be instructed by the board and the general manager to enforce our community’s rules consistently,” he wrote. “This applies to all members of our community.”
In a telephone interview, Childs emphasized that the board’s obligation to protect confidential information limits its ability to defend its decisions against public criticism.
“There’s always more to the story, and we’re not allowed to talk about confidential information because that’s what the law requires,” he said.
Social Media Response
The confrontation quickly became a focus of criticism on social media, where residents expressed outrage over what they perceived as the directors’ refusal to shake Carrillo’s hand.
The turnout followed a Nov. 15 Facebook post by Carrillo’s wife, Sherry Luman-Carrillo, sharing a message from her husband requesting residents’ moral support at the meeting, along with a photo of Carrillo and Leo.
In a subsequent post, she thanked residents for their support and said the controversy was about more than a skateboarding citation. She urged residents to elect directors who would listen, communicate openly and treat neighbors respectfully.
In a Nov. 18 interview, Carrillo described the meeting as “bittersweet.”
“It was sweet because I was so honored that I had that many people show up or even care enough about what was going on,” he said.
But he said he was disappointed by the directors’ response and believes the controversy reflects broader problems with the association’s treatment of members.
“I don’t think it’s about the dog. I don’t think it’s about me,” he said. “I think it’s about the things that I’m bringing up.”














